logo.png

YouTube Shorts vs. Long-Form Content: What's the Best Strategy for Channels Under 1,000 Subscribers?

Saturday, September 28, 2024

BetterFlow Blog/YouTuber Tools & Resources/YouTube Shorts vs. Long-Form Content: What's the Best Strategy for Channels Under 1,000 Subscribers?

This Week's YouTube Strategy Recap:

YouTube Shorts vs. Long-Form Content:What's the Best Strategy for Channels Under 1,000 Subscribers?

New information from one of the top industry leaders in YouTube strategy, so you can learn from the best and explode your channel!

Sean Cannell — founder of Think Media, with over 3M subscribers — recently uploaded a video on his new strategy for growth using YouTube Shorts and long-form videos.

Here’s the summary:
​
​If you're trying to grow your YouTube channel, especially if you haven't hit that first 1,000 subscribers yet, you're likely considering how to balance your content between YouTube Shorts and long-form content. Both formats have their advantages and disadvantages, and choosing the right strategy can be the difference between your channel plateauing (or declining), or you waking up tomorrow with all of your YouTube dreams coming true.

Let’s break down the key aspects of each to help you decide what’s best for your channel:

The Appeal of YouTube Shorts

1. Quick and Easy to Produce:

One of the major advantages of YouTube Shorts is that they can be created more quickly and easily. You don’t need fancy equipment—a smartphone and the YouTube app can handle everything from shooting to editing. This makes Shorts an accessible option for beginners who may not have the budget or expertise for high-end production.​

2. Potential for Viral Success:

YouTube Shorts can rack up views fast, sometimes going viral unexpectedly. While these views might not always translate into monetary success, the exposure can be invaluable, especially for channels just starting out. So, if you’re just looking to cross that first milestone of 1,000 subscribers, then Shorts can be a great aid in getting there.

3. High Engagement Rates:

Since Shorts are less than 60 seconds, they’re more likely to be watched in full, which is a key factor in engagement. Quick, consumable content tends to hook viewers more easily than longer videos. This can really boost your views and reach on the platform.

4. Easy to Repurpose Across Platforms:

Short vertical videos can be shared across platforms like Instagram, TikTok, and LinkedIn. By creating one piece of content, you can maximize your reach across multiple social networks.

5. Complement Long-Form Content:

Shorts can act as teasers or samples for your long-form content, much like a Cinnabon sample entices you to buy a full-sized bun. However, not all viewers will make the leap from Shorts to long-form videos, so consider Shorts as a gateway rather than a guaranteed conversion tool.

6. Attractive to Brands:

Brands are increasingly seeking sponsorships with vertical content creators, making Shorts a potential revenue stream. For example, one creator, Ryan Johnson, built a $12,000 monthly business through a mix of brand deals, Shorts, and long-form content.

The Downsides of YouTube Shorts

1. Less Depth:

Shorts are great for quick hits of content, but you can’t dive deep into a topic in under 60 seconds. If you’re trying to establish authority in your niche, Shorts alone won’t get you there.

2. Different Audience Behavior:

Shorts viewers often have shorter attention spans and may not be as engaged or invested as long-form viewers. This can affect your channel’s overall quality of engagement and connection with your audience.

3. Lower Monetization Potential:

Although YouTube has improved the monetization of Shorts, the revenue per thousand views (RPM) is still significantly lower than that of long-form content. For example, while a viral Short might get millions of views, the earnings from those views can be minimal compared to long-form videos.

4. Algorithm Dependence:

YouTube Shorts rely heavily on the algorithm for discovery, which can be both a blessing and a curse. While Shorts might get millions of views, they’re also subject to the whims of the algorithm, which makes it a less reliable strategy for long-term success.

5. Shorter Lifespan:

Shorts tend to have a quick burst of popularity and then fade, unlike long-form videos that can continue to attract views for months or even years.

6. Limited Call to Action:

YouTube removed the ability to add clickable links to Shorts, which limits the effectiveness of affiliate marketing, promotions, or other calls to action. Converting Shorts viewers into long-term subscribers or customers can also be challenging.

The Strengths of Long-Form Content

1. Higher Monetization:

Long-form content typically generates higher RPMs, meaning more money from ad revenue. Additionally, you can include multiple ads throughout longer videos, further increasing your earning potential.

2. Stronger Audience Connection:

Long-form videos allow for deeper connections with your audience. If someone sticks around for a 20-30 minute video, they’re more likely to be genuinely interested in what you have to say. This builds stronger relationships with viewers, which can lead to higher engagement and loyalty.

3. Builds Authority:

In-depth content showcases your expertise. If your goal is to establish a personal brand or be seen as an authority in your niche, long-form videos are far more effective than Shorts. People get to know you and trust you through the rich, detailed content you provide.

4. More Profitable Subscribers:

Subscribers who engage with long-form content tend to be more valuable in the long run. They’re more likely to make purchases, engage with your brand, and become long-term fans. In fact, many business leaders, like the CMO of HubSpot, believe YouTube subscribers are the most valuable subscribers on the internet.

5. Higher-Quality Brand Deals:

While you can secure brand deals with Shorts, long-form videos often attract higher-paying sponsorships. These integrations provide brands with more value, as they can include multiple mentions, detailed product reviews, and stronger calls to action.

The Challenges of Long-Form Content

1. Higher Production Costs and Time:

Long-form videos require more planning, filming, and editing. If you’re creating a high-quality video podcast or educational content, you might need multiple cameras, professional lighting, and good audio equipment, which increases both the time and money invested.

2. Lower Engagement Rates:

Long-form videos often have lower percentage engagement, as viewers are less likely to watch the entire video. However, even if a 30-minute video only retains 30% of viewers, that could still mean someone is watching for 10 minutes or more, which is a huge win for your channel’s performance.

3. Slower Growth: 

It's true that one of the cons of long-form content is slower growth. Shorts can feel like a sugar rush — instant views, fast growth, and more subscribers. But just like a sugar high, it fades, and you're left wondering what you've truly built. Long-form content is more like going to the gym and eating healthy. It may not give you results as quickly, but it builds a strong foundation for your brand, fostering a loyal audience and deeper connections.

So, Which Strategy Is Best for You?

If the above info hasn’t yet helped clarify which direction you want to go with your Shorts vs Long-form strategy, then here’s some additional questions you can ask yourself to gain more clarity:

What Are Your Goals?

Ultimately, the choice between shorts and long-form content comes down to your goals. What are you trying to achieve on YouTube? Is it all about views, impact, subscriber quality, or healthy growth? Clarifying your goals is essential because many creators fall into the trap of chasing views as their main metric, but it may not be the right one for everyone.

What Format Fits Your Strengths? 

What format fits your channel’s niche, and furthermore, your strengths? Some content works well in shorts, but may fall flat in long-form videos, and vice versa. Tutorials like deep dives into WordPress or Excel are prime examples of content that thrives in long-form. Conversely, some creators shine in short-form video, where they can showcase quick tips or snappy edits. Aligning with your strengths as a creator is where the magic happens.

How Much Time Do You Have to Create Content?

You also need to factor in your schedule. Shorts are a great format for beginners who want to dip their toes into content creation without committing to the time-intensive process of creating long-form videos. It’s about getting into the routine, developing your skills, and starting to build momentum. If you can’t commit to long-form yet, don’t let that stop you from starting with shorts. Work with what’s realistic for you right now, and level up as you go. The sooner you start, the sooner you can improve, monetize, and reinvest in your channel. Remember, it's not about your resources, but your resourcefulness.

Can You Do Both?

If you have the resources, doing both formats might make the most sense, especially for certain niches. For example, if you're doing video podcasts, shorts are a no-brainer. You can repurpose clips from your longer interviews as shorts that seamlessly connect with your main content. However, it's essential to maintain consistency in branding between your shorts and long-form videos. If the visual style and branding align, it makes it easier for your audience to transition from one format to another.

Key Insights to Consider

Both is Usually Best

Eventually, most creators should aim to use both shorts and long-form content strategically. As Dave Ramsey said, you should be platform agnostic, and this can apply to content formats as well. Your ultimate goal should be to spread your message in whatever format works best, whether that's shorts, long-form videos, podcasts, or a combination of all three. In the beginning, it’s essential to focus. Especially in the "side hustle" and "solopreneur" seasons, where you might not have the bandwidth to do everything. But eventually, when you scale, doing both is the ideal strategy.

Native Content Wins

Native content is always better than repurposed content. If you're serious about making shorts work, create them with that format in mind rather than trying to force a long-form video into multiple shorts. If you're doing long-form content, invest time in creating high-quality, high-value videos. A good YouTube video with a strong title, thumbnail, and content can have a long shelf life, driving search traffic and recommendations for months or even years.

Final Thoughts

Both formats have their challenges. Shorts are relatively new, and long-form content has been around since the beginning of YouTube, but competition is fierce in both areas. The right choice depends on your content, your audience, and your goals.

If you’re under 1,000 subscribers, YouTube Shorts can be a powerful tool for growing your channel quickly and getting that initial exposure. However, long-form content is where the real value lies, both in terms of audience connection and monetization.

A hybrid approach might be the best strategy — use Shorts to build awareness and draw people in, but lean into long-form content to build lasting relationships and grow your channel in a sustainable way.

To wrap up, here are five tips for growing your channel with Shorts and Long-form content:

  • Use both formats eventually: Be format-agnostic to reach as many people as possible, but focus on what you can do now based on your time and resources.
  • Leverage video podcasts: If you’re creating video podcasts, repurpose clips for both long-form and shorts.
  • Create native content: Shorts should be made with shorts in mind, not just cut down from long-form videos.
  • Focus on one high-quality long-form video per week: If you’re just starting or still in the side hustle phase, focus on high-value content before getting distracted by shorts or social media.
  • Stay focused and strategic: Prioritize long-form content, then repurpose on YouTube before expanding to other platforms.

Want Weekly Content Ideas and Tool Suggestions that will help you master your YouTuber game? Join our weekly newsletter!  

Looking for a practical way to implement these strategies?

We’ve got you covered! Well… almost. We’re launching the Ultimate YouTuber Workflow very soon which takes all of the best YouTube Strategies and puts them into a daily workflow for you. This way, you don’t even have to remember the strategies. The workflow does it for you!

Follow the flow and watch your channel grow with The Ultimate YouTuber Workflow!

customer1 png

Hi, I Am D'Laina Hunt

Founder & CEO of Better Flow

Being a content creator isn't for the faint of heart, and we know that. That's why we're here to empower and enrich you with all the resources and knowledge we can get out hands on. Thank you for visiting our blog. We are rooting for you in your journey!

1 png

Coming Soon

The Ultimate YouTube Workflow is a powerful tool that will change your approach to content creation, for the better.

It teaches you best practices and helps you incorporate the best-known strategies for growth on YouTube, right into your content. Creating content that actually gets views has never been easier.

Super excited about this product? We are, too! 

Get notified when it launches: